Reviews
Behold! A Great Album

A complete departure from Daniel Anderson's claim to fame, Idiot Pilot, The Ghost And The Grace delivers a folksy brand of facing life, death, and in between.
It was hard for me to sink my teeth into Behold! A Pale Horse for a lot of reasons — 99.9% of which didn't pertain to the album. But, every once in a while I would pop the disc into my CD Player and give it a go. (That's right, an actual CD player!) My first reaction was that I loved the first track, What Have I Done? Seemingly a lament of a hearse driver — it ends with my favorite thing in music: a bleak mantra stopped too abruptly for comfort. As the album carried on, though, later tracks tended to fade back and get lost in the backdrop of whatever I was doing. However, soon it seemed that with every listen a new song would stick out to me — making me consult the back of the CD so I could make a mental note. I soon realized that my initial reaction was due to my inability to sit still for 53 minutes and 43 seconds and the album proved to be an elegant, somewhat gritty composition of fine instrumentation and vocal tonalities.
The wide range of instruments (all played by Daniel) is a feat in itself. But, the amount of range within how those instruments are presented is another. On Behold! you'll get pumping tracks of energy such as A Pretty Good Place To Start as well as calmer bedtime tracks like Antlion and After All. These different soundscapes give lots of room for new instruments to shine — hammering in the departure that is this album. Every little toy — be it horn, piano, banjo, or string — gives each song something special all the while being tied together with harmony and catchy, examining lyrics.
I think the lyrics really do give something special to Behold! Songs like How Far You Go, My Shell Is Broken, and Genetics are not only pleasurable to listen to but beg for the listener to dissect and really throw themselves into the music. Each track has that quality which makes for your favorites to be quite indiscernible. Behold!'s closing track, After All, however can be called out as one of my favorites — seemingly paralleling What Have I Done? with its repetitious ending. The applause following that sounds like it's coming from a lonely back porch in the bayou is certainly well deserved.
Altogether, you have to hand it to any artist who throws him- or herself into the threshold of a new genre. Often times you won't see side projects like this — so able to be different. Too many times an alternative effort will just be a warped replica of the previous. Take Handsome, a project of Hemet's Peter Mengede or Fever Ray, project of The Knife's Karin Dreijer Andersson. While I love those albums I can't help but think they did it for no other reason than a new name.
But, Daniel completes his shift well. With Idiot Pilot being a heavier rock-electronica fusion it was hard to expect something as different as this. The album still dons the occasional and familiar spastic scream but overall this is a true folk effort and a great gasp of fresh air from an already fresh artist. Behold!
This album was comped to me by Daniel himself during his epic journey of self-promotion. I would like to thank him endlessly for seeking me out and his interest in Whalereviews. Hopefully, my procrastination of this review didn't have too much of a buzzkill.
Pick up Behold! A Pale Horse at his website: theghostandthegrace.com. Even if you're not buying the album, check it out, he's got some nice stuff on his blog.
'Tis The Season

For the past two weeks I've been waking up to what's inevitable this time of year — Christmas music. Uhg, the same ole same ole can get a little monotonous after a while for music snobs such as myself. So, before you dust off Bing Crosby's White Christmas or dig through your collection to find that compilation of unknowns doing the all too familiar — let Whalereviews give you some suggestions. Maybe it'll keep you dashing through that Winter Wonderland instead of slaying someone in it.
They Might Be Giants
They Might Be Giants In Holidayland, 2001
Always spunky, this EP is a good starter for a long night of hanging lights, pounding beers, shaving kittens, or whatever you do to get ready for Christmas.
Sufjan Stevens
Songs For Christmas, 2006
If you're looking for every Christmas song ever made (and then some) this is for you. Clocking in at just over 2 hours and spreading over five volumes this is the most beautiful holiday compilation I've ever found — it's sure to relax and cater to any Christmas spirit.
Vince Guaraldi
A Charlie Brown Christmas, 1965
Probably not a new addition to your stack but who can argue with this one? Seriously, I don't know if this'll ever go out of style. Religion!
Various Artists
Christmas On Death Row, 1996
Hey, remember 2Pac and how he was the shining beacon of Death Row Records? Well... he's not on this album, sorry. This album isn't even particularly good — you just can't not love not loving it. You laugh now but all your friends will think you're cool for owning one of the few Christmas albums to brandish a parental advisory sticker.
The Flaming Lips
Christmas On Mars, 2008
Oops! There's that parental advisory again... Is this even technically a Christmas album? Who Cares, it's the Flaming Lips!
Bootsy Collins
Christmas Is 4 Ever, 2006
Have you ever heard this? Yeah, neither have I but it somehow made the list — on sheer merit.
Various Artists
Elf Soundtrack, 2003
This is a great collection of classics — and if you're a fan of the film — it's sure to strike a chord in your Christmasy heart. At least, until the New Year rolls around and you get too shitty to remember any of it.
Henry Rollins
A Lump Of Coal, 1991
When he's not yelling at you he's lining up other bands to create what I can only describe as a "rather interesting" Christmas compilation. I've only heard this album once — like in ninth grade — and the remembrance of it never fails to peek out from behind my hippocampus during the holiday season. But by January it creeps back inwards to hang out with Crystal Pepsi and that time I farted in gym class.
Al Green
White Christmas, 1986
What would seem to be a very vanilla holiday album, isn't. Al Green charms the pants off of the holiday season without becoming dull — so much so that I wanna lay down with the Yuletide and show it some tenderness.
Various Artists
A Colbert Christmas – The Greatest Gift Of All!
This album is the accompaniment to his televised Christmas special of the same name (aired almost an entire month early!). I haven't actually heard this one either but you can't go wrong with Stephen Colbert. It's sure to be a blast of hilarity and a zap of freshness to your holiday music lineup. It's only available for download on iTunes.
Twisted Sister
A Twisted Christmas, 2006
When that fourth cup of egg nog has pushed you over the edge you know it's time for this gem. With Dee Snider's magic touch on the classics you'll be able to trick your brain into thinking it's getting festive traditions when it's really getting men who wore make-up and stretchy-pants. Go ahead, pass out in your Santa suit with class.
And there you have it. Happy holidays.
I Paid $7 For A 3-track Disc... Totally Worth It

I'll keep this short and sweet because I just needed to write something and I've been exhausting this disc ever since I got it.
When I saw Big Business open up for The Melvins I went to the merch booth to pick up a cool shirt where I also couldn't resist the urge to get their new Tour EP III. Well, I'm glad I gave into the merch booth because this EP is amazing. The two new tracks, Cold Lunch and The Drift, hit hard and offer a good glimpse into where their next album is going. They also pull off a well-done cover of Shocking Blue's Send Me A Postcard. What I like about the cover is how Jared Warren doesn't change the lyrics to assume his gender (Shocking Blue had a female singer) when he sings "How can I make you understand? I wanna be a woman." And in the third verse when that lyric is repeated he instead leaves a gap, "I wanna be a __man." It's by every means a chance for them to do a fun cover but things like that show audiences that they still have a consciousness about what they're doing.
My favorite track is The Drift which, they performed at the show. It starts with a droning, fist-pumping beat as Coady Willis smacks the drums waiting for Warren's bass licks — soon to be joined by the guitar of newcomer Toshi Kasai. It's just a hard-hitting song that maintains it's power while still achieving Big Business' token sludge sound.
It's just too bad you can't buy it aside from the tour (yet) but when you can I highly suggest you do buy it. And, of course, when the next album comes out I have no doubt I'll suggest that too. Maybe I'll even review it here.
Crying Wolves...?

with Carrie Hempfer
Carrie Hempfer is a lost creative soul searching for the true meaning of graphic design. She dreams of one day taking her design education and applying it to the art of the pastry. She also dreams of chocolate mountains.
Visit her site: www.carriehempfer.com
Idiot Pilot has come a long way since I received the independently released version of Strange We Should Meet Here in a hand-addressed envelope (the one not designed by Asterik Studio). But, have they come as far as their newfound press would claim? With special guest Carrie Hempfer, their new album, Wolves, will be put through the wringer in order to find out.
Randy : Round One
- - - - -
As hefty as their first release was, my initial feelings upon hearing Wolves was that it had become another earmark on a long list of bands who squeeze out an overproduced, undercut sophomore album after signing to a major label. Upon listening to it over and over — as the first three tracks were becoming a fungal growth on the Top-100-lovin' side of my brain — I've come to realize that I might've made a premature assumption. I still think it lacks a good amount of the grit found on their debut but, it's not erased completely. Idiot Pilot still regains my confidence with their awkward transitions from ambient soundtrack beats to throat-burning screams. A well-balanced blend of these two genres keeps the album (and the band) feeling new and not bogged down by being an "electronic" band or a "hardcore" band or a "post-hardcore" band or even an "avant-electro-rock" band. Although preferring Strange We Should Meet Here — Wolves does leave me wanting more.
Carrie : Round One
- - - - -
Wolves is as well-balanced as a two year old laying in the middle of a grocery store aisle. The album begins tame, a bit poppy, then moves into a state of melodramatic pleading with Cruel World Enterprise. If this song doesn't receive your desired attention, the screaming that ensues — beginning with Red Museum and full-blown in Planted in the Dark — certainly will. Yes, the intention behind this album to take you on an emotional journey through the fusing of several genres of music is attained, but listening to it is almost as tolerable as the above mentioned child I step around to grab my Raisin Bran. To me, Strange We Should Meet Here proves to be much more balanced not only in it's entirety but within each track. At every interval, melodic singing is met head on by bouts of screaming. That harmony creates an accessibility that Wolves only claims to have.
Randy : Round Two
- - - - -
The overall tone of Cruel World Enterprise may seem a little ballad-esque but, with the lyric "We will concentrate on ruining your face." I think the song may have a bit more depth than "melodramatic pleading" — as do most of the songs. If you start at the album's halfway-point, Cruel World Enterprise, and work your way to Planted In The Dark you'll definitely hear an escalation from calm to heavy. But, because the CD is capped by the real ballad of the album, Recurring Dream, rather than Planted In The Dark it leaves Wolves feeling unbalanced. This album's harmony works more in sections rather than as a whole — something that Strange We Should Meet Here didn't struggle with at all. Every track contains a unique interplay of genres which I find intriguing and well-rounded. However, some tracks lose their connection to the rest. I almost want to reorder the album to see if I can make the puzzle pieces fit.
Carrie : Round Two
- - - - -
Perhaps reordering the tracks would be beneficial to the flow of the album. Maybe that would even help with the fact that I cannot distinguish the first 5 tracks from each other; they all seem to blur together to create a long-winded pop epic. Mainly this is because there are not enough twists and surprises there to grab and hold my attention. When you get to the second half of the album you are hit over the head repeatedly with surprises. So much so that it becomes too much to handle. When Whalereviews asked me to pick my favorite song I did narrow it down to the first half — out of contempt for the rest of the album — but then struggled to call one out in particular. After many repeat listenings, I finally decided on Retina and the Sky for it's slightly less mainstream pop feel. Or, maybe it simply bothers me the least.
Windup
- - - - -
Well, there you have it. One thing that seems clear is that we both enjoy Idiot Pilot's first album more than their latest. When you get down to the details, however, it's a little blurry. There are things on this album that do need improvement. But, unless they feel like spending the money to re-record, reprint and redistribute Wolves based upon the opinion of two people, we're not likely to see those changes. So, for now you'll have to make due.
A Curse Becomes A Blessing

Seamless. That's how I would describe the newest release from The Mars Volta.
The thing I love about The Mars Volta is how they always strive to create a progressive musical interweave between all the tracks on an album. Sometimes I don't know where one track ends and another begins... I like that. I also love that they create albums around one central theme. Many artists do this — and of course by "this" I mean the ever-pursued concept album. Some artists succeed while others do not. In my opinion The Mars Volta have always succeeded substantially and in the case of The Bedlam In Goliath I think it is their best yet; surpassing both De-Loused In The Comatorium and Frances The Mute.
Let me say that I remain content in my long-affirmed decision that Frances The Mute is wholly their best album but, Bedlam is far more conceptually solid than any album thus far. The story of De-Loused was, to me, like watching a Paul Thomas Anderson film. Stuff is happening, it's interesting but, it doesn't seem to matter until the fantastic end (i.e. Take The Veil Cerpin Taxt). Frances The Mute was executed just the way it should've been; confusingly unified and descriptive but devoid of any conclusion. That was of course because it's story was not really a story but a catalogue of events and characters. In Bedlam I feel you get the best of both worlds. It has both the unification of narrative and a powerful ending. Not to mention great music.
Within the first two tracks I can detect hints of the horn arrangements of Frances The Mute and moaning guitar stylings of Amputechture. Sometimes repeating rhythms throughout multiple albums is a warning sign of a "one-note-band" but, in The Mars Volta's case it's done with such consciousness and method that it just further conveys their sense of synthesis. Being their most aggressive album yet (proclaimed by Omar Rodriguez-Lopez) I'm impressed with it's attention to detail and variety. One of the reasons I admire Frances The Mute so much is because of it's colorful palette so it's nice to hear the suggestions of Funk on the track Ilyena and vaguely... vaguely reminiscent licks of Speed Metal on Wax Simulacra. There are so many blends on this album all held together with an established musical style and continued experimentation.
The one-up this album does have over the rest is that it's by far the most intriguing. Laced and laden with real-life curses that overshadowed the band after Rodriguez-Lopez purchased a Ouija board from the Holy Land — The Bedlam In Goliath gives us a recount of their hex as a way to loosen it's grip on them. You really have to read the whole thing if you want to delve deep into it because I can't explain it all in this review. Or you can play the online game. I recommend both.
But, I digress — The Mars Volta is a great band and they make great albums. You should expect nothing less with The Bedlam In Goliath. Done and done.
Emo Gone Awry

I'll start off this review by saying; I liked Finch's first album, What It Is To Burn. That is... until I heard Say Hello To Sunshine.
I owned Say Hello To Sunshine for a few months without even listening to the album's entirety until one day I decided to give it an uninterrupted, attentive listen. To this day (about two-and-a-half years later) I have never gone back to their pop-emo style of What It Is To Burn. Yeah, that album was catchy but I no longer cared because their new stuff was a giant leap off of a skyscraper in a flaming monster truck from the old. Instead of wanting to tap my foot and sway, their new CD made me want to punch through walls and scream in the face of random strangers.
It doesn't take long to know you're getting a completely different style with Say Hello To Sunshine. The music is heavier and granular, there's a scream around every corner and the lyrics paint abstract pictures with bloodthirsty irrationality. Lyrically, Nate Barcalow has evolved tremendously by seemingly giving his lyrics notional qualities much like The Mars Volta or R.E.M. But, even though you have no clue what Barcalow is saying there are pungent aromas of frustration, violence and the need for salvation seeping from his straining vocal chords. It's this frustration that gives the album depth where it would otherwise be lacking.
However, the lyrics alone don't make the album. The guitars' ability to duel the short snare snaps and cymbal clashes give this album the same amount of rhythm and catchiness of their first record — it's just been given some adrenaline and a rusty knife.
I spent the last two-and-a-half years loving this album and reveling about how they couldn't have asked for a better way to end their career as Finch (yes, they broke up). But, alas, that time is over as recently it has been announced that their new album is in the making (yes, they're back together). Although nothing has yet to be officially released from their new endeavors I'm positive it will be nothing like Say Hello To Sunshine thus, not peaking my interest. This album just seems like something you couldn't create twice — at least by a band of this nature... no offense.
Conversational Qualities

A few years ago I was listening to this band called Surrounded By Lions who hail from Bellevue, WA — not too far from my hometown of Everett, WA. Surrounded By Lions uniquely blended Pop and Rock within the voice of James Hill whose pipes could produce both a striking calmness and some fantastic yelping. Evolution Vol. 1 was (and still is) one of those albums I'd play whenever I didn't know what else to listen to — it'll always be there for me in times of need. A while after Vol. 1 they released Evolution Vol. 2 — also very impressive.
Then, like many bands barely out of high school who don't hit the big-time, they soon parted ways for college and/or other projects. One member, Kyle O'Quin, went on to form Kay Kay And His Weathered Underground while James Hill focused on his solo career. So far he's put out four full-length recordings — all of which you can download for free on his website! — and all of which I have thoroughly enjoyed. The "World On Fire!" E.P. is no different — by way of me enjoying it. But, musically — although nicely done and fresh — it leaves me wanting to backtrack to his previous works.
The main qualm I have with this 4-song cut is that it completely abandons his acoustic aesthetic. For me, it is absent of that conversational quality that he had with his guitar. This is most evident in the re-recording of a lovely duet entitled, That's Love. The original recording was a gorgeously intimate lyrical conversation between Terra Brigando (who is replaced by Amy Rockwell in the new version) and James Hill. Not since Almost Paradise had a duet seemed so powerful to me.* Adding the piano, drums and strings took away those elements that made the previous version so great. Instead of listening to two people connect musically I felt I was listening to two people simply record together. The other revisited song, It's My Day, also feels foreign compared to it's original while Something's Wrong and Nothing's Gonna Change, the other tracks, provide a good listen but gain little momentum compared to his one man, one guitar endeavors.
I hate to come down so hard on this album because it really is good, it's just not what I'm used to. Don't get me wrong, I am all for change in music (Bob Dylan going electric, The Beatles going psychedelic, The Deftones going White Pony and even William Shatner making a comeback) but this evolution just feels unnecessary and I believe James and his guitar could have such a beautiful future as a monogamous pair.
